Many people in America are having a conversation about immigration right now. Many people who may or may not have been interested in politics up until this point are talking about immigration policy in America. We should all be having this conversation right now. I have spent the past week trying to logic, yelling, cursing, begging, calling, writing, crying, and then doing it all over again. It is exhausting trying to make people see what is right in front of them. I have watched hardened newsmen and women voices crack with emotion as they try to keep their emotions from coming out as they report the news. I feel their pain. And I have heard the arguments against those who are screaming that the sky is falling. I reject those arguments. Here is a breakdown of the arguments I have seen and my basis for rejecting them.
1. You didn’t seem to care about this before. Obama was doing the same thing
This does not forgive Obama for not fixing a broken system, it simply states that the system went from broken to abusive. If we were detaining children under Obama, that was equally wrong as what is happening now. However, we can’t go back and change what has already happened we can only prevent things from happening in the future. Just because it wasn’t changed before does not mean that it shouldn’t change now. That is akin to saying it isn’t a drunk driver’s fault for killing someone because no one stopped the last person who drove the car from drinking. The result is the same regardless.
2. What about the American kids here. Why don’t you care about them?/ These aren’t American kids, why should we care what happens to them
Let me tell you about the kids here in America. First, many kids in America are first generation Americans. They are in your neighborhood and in your schools. Your kids know them and are friends with them. They are kids, just like yours and just like mine. They have dreams and they have hopes and they are afraid. They play video games and watch youtube and talk back to their mom. These are actual human beings. They are not animals. They are not murders and gang members. They are not evil. They are children.
Please note, that this goes for the black kids in America too. They are also humans and not animals and gang members. They do not deserve to be shot in the back by police. They do not deserve to be beaten by the police. That isn’t how justice is supposed to work in America and we are killing our children. The screaming babies recorded at the border, the videos of children being shot in the streets of America, the overwhelming crisis of school shooting are not fake news. This is real, and this is how we are treating children in the United States of America and no one does anything because these kids are too young to have a voice of their own.
As an adult, it is my job and your job to protect the next generation of Americans. And let me make this clear, some of those screaming kids at the border are going to come to America and become legal citizens. They are going to vote someday. They are going to parent American children and they are not going to let this happen again. I have faith in them. In 20 or 30 years I hope these kids become members of Congress and members of the media and they call America to task for what it did and defended back in the summer of 2018. I expect them to be the ones who skillfully write the laws to protect the kids we did not. Because after all, that’s what American immigrants do and have done for the past 400 years in America.
3. Why don’t they go back to where they came from? Why are they coming here if it is so bad?
I suppose from that logic, locking them in cages and feeding them isn’t the worst thing they have been through by a long shot. However, I just want you to put yourself in that position. Think about escaping hell and finally making it to the place that you believe to be the greatest country on earth, that you have heard will protect you and keep you safe. This dreamland where your children can be safe, and you finally make it there, making it through the journey and they take your kids away and lock them in a cage and then ship them 3000 miles away. You would not be okay with that.
Furthermore, there is the story of the HS St. Louis a ship carrying Jewish refugees from Germany in 1939. We turned them away and almost half of the Jews we turned away on that ship were killed in the Holocaust. America let them die because we had laws about refugees and immigrants. It was illegal for them to be here. America let them die because the people of America said it wasn’t their problem and they needed to go back where they came from. America killed Jews in the Holocaust not by gassing them themselves, but by not allowing them to flee a place that was dangerous because we needed to protect our borders and the Jews would just take resources and jobs from Americans. They weren’t humans in the eyes of America. America killed them, under a democratic progressive president at that. America did that.
4. If they weren’t doing something illegal they wouldn’t be detained
I expect everyone else to reject it as well. When humanity is no longer humanity and the world is nothing but us versus them then we have failed at being a civilized society. America is already lost at that point.